The seven independence tests in Provision 10
Provision 10 says the board should identify in the annual report each non-executive director it considers independent. It then lists circumstances that are likely to impair, or could appear to impair, independence. The list is not exhaustive. A director can be found independent despite one of them, but the board has to give a clear explanation of why.
- Is or has been an employee of the company or group within the last five years.
- Has, or has had within the last three years, a material business relationship with the company, directly or as a partner, shareholder, director or senior employee of a body that has one.
- Receives or has received remuneration from the company apart from a director's fee, takes part in the company's share option or performance-related pay schemes, or is a member of its pension scheme.
- Has close family ties with any of the company's advisers, directors or senior employees.
- Holds cross-directorships or has significant links with other directors through involvement in other companies or bodies.
- Represents a significant shareholder.
- Has served on the board for more than nine years from the date of their first appointment.
Independent NED, non-independent NED and executive director
| Independent NED | Non-independent NED | Executive director | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Works in the business | No | No | Yes |
| Typical example | Experienced outsider chosen for judgment | Investor director, former CEO, founder's adviser | Chief executive, CFO |
| Counts towards the Code's half-independent board | Yes | No | No |
| Can sit on the audit and remuneration committees under the Code | Yes | No | No |
| Paid by | A fee under a letter of appointment | A fee, or nothing if paid by the investor | Salary under a service contract |
| Legal duties | A director's duties | A director's duties | A director's duties |
Why boards need them, and how many
Provision 11 of the Code asks for at least half the board, excluding the chair, to be independent non-executive directors. Provision 24 says the audit committee should be made up of independent NEDs, at least three, or two in a smaller company, and Provision 32 says the same of the remuneration committee. Provision 12 asks the board to appoint one of them as senior independent director, a sounding board for the chair and a route for shareholders if the normal channels fail. Provision 13 has the chair meet the non-executives without the executives present.
Private companies have no such rules, but investors borrow the logic. A venture or private equity investor taking a seat often asks for an independent NED too, precisely because their own director is not independent, and a lender or acquirer gives more weight to a board where someone in the room owes nothing to the founder.
What the role pays and what it takes
Published fees are for quoted companies. The Spencer Stuart UK Board Index 2023 put the average base fee for a non-executive director at £76,868 across the 150 largest companies with a premium London listing, with an average of £26,260 on top for chairing the audit committee. The BDO AIM 100 remuneration report 2025 found a median base fee of £58,000, and the QCA non-executive director survey 2022 an average of £40,500 across small and mid-sized quoted companies. Private company fees are not surveyed and are usually lower, sometimes paid partly in equity, which matters because share options are one of the Code's independence tests.
The time is the part people underestimate. The getoperators NED pages use 25 to 35 days a year for a listed board and 12 to 24 in a private company, more for a committee chair and far more in a crisis.
How executives actually get their first independent seat
- Lead with one specialism the board lacks. Audit committees need recent, relevant financial experience; remuneration committees need someone who has run pay; technology and cyber are now asked for by name.
- Start private. A first seat on a private, charity or NHS board builds the board record that listed company nominations committees look for.
- Watch the independence tests before you accept. A consulting contract with the same company, or options in lieu of fee, can cost you the independent label.
- Run a fractional seat alongside. Many portfolio executives combine one or two board roles with fractional executive work, which pays more per day and keeps their operating judgment current.
Listing on getoperators
On getoperators there is no registration fee and nothing is taken from your rate. You set the day rate, it is shown on your public profile with your availability, and companies contact you directly; you contract with them and invoice them yourself. When a company engages someone it met here, the company pays getoperators a fee of its own, on top of your rate, never out of it. Every profile is checked by hand against LinkedIn and a CV before it goes live, and only people who have held the seat are accepted. Operator Pro, an optional membership, gives more visibility in your seat, and you do not need it to be listed.
Fractional seats run at very different rates from board fees: in the UK a fractional CFO is published at £800 to £1,500 a day and a fractional CISO at £900 to £1,500. On the bench, James W. was global head of audit for investment banking at Credit Suisse and UBS and sits in the CFO seat, and Andrew F. and Jagjot S. are CISOs. A company considering you for a board seat sees your availability before it calls, which is the overboarding question answered in public.
Common questions
What makes a non-executive director independent under the UK Code?
Having none of the relationships listed in Provision 10, such as employment in the last five years, a material business relationship in the last three, extra pay or share options, close family ties, cross-directorships, representing a significant shareholder or more than nine years on the board. The board decides and explains.
Does an independent NED stop being independent after nine years?
Not automatically. Serving more than nine years from first appointment is one of the Provision 10 circumstances, so a board that still considers the director independent must give a clear explanation in the annual report.
Can an investor director count as an independent non-executive?
Usually not. Representing a significant shareholder is one of the Provision 10 tests, so an investor's nominee is normally treated as a non-independent non-executive director.
Can an independent NED also do fractional work for the same company?
It puts independence at risk. Being paid by the company beyond a director's fee is one of the Provision 10 tests, and the work would also need managing as a conflict. Keep paid executive work for companies whose boards you do not sit on.
More of them, on hiring, contracts and what a fractional engagement costs, on the fractional executive FAQ.
Read next
Related reading
- Same Table, Different Law. Board of Trustees vs Board of Directors, and Which Seat Suits Your Portfolio
- What Is a COO? The Chief Operating Officer, Explained (and When You Actually Need One)
- What Is a CFO? What the Chief Financial Officer Really Does (Hint: It Isn't Bookkeeping)
- What Is a CMO? Why the Chief Marketing Officer Is Judged on Revenue, Not Posts
- Executive Chairman or Non-Executive Chairman? The Title Decides Who Really Runs the Company