Same Table, Different Law. Board of Trustees vs Board of Directors, and Which Seat Suits Your Portfolio

A board of trustees is the group of people with legal control of a charity, and a board of directors is the group with legal control of a company. The main differences are who they answer to, whether they are paid and which law applies: trustees act for the charity's purposes and answer to the Charity Commission, are normally unpaid and follow charity law, while directors act for the company's members, are often paid and follow the Companies Act 2006. The two overlap more than most people expect. In a charitable company the trustees are also the company's directors, so the same people sit on both boards at once.

Charity points are from the Charity Commission's The essential trustee (CC3) and Charity types: how to choose a structure (CC22a), with trustee pay covered by Charity Commission guidance CC11, trustee expenses and payments, all on gov.uk. Board fees are from the BDO AIM 100 remuneration report 2025. This is not legal advice.

What a board of trustees is

The Charity Commission's guidance says trustees have independent control over, and legal responsibility for, a charity's management and administration. Its title does not matter: everyone properly appointed to the charity's governing body is a charity trustee, whether the charity calls them trustees, directors, governors or committee members. Together they are the board of trustees.

Their job is to make sure the charity pursues its purposes for the public benefit, follows its governing document and the law, acts in its best interests, manages its resources responsibly, acts with reasonable care and skill, and is accountable. They can delegate work to staff and committees, but CC3 is clear that they cannot delegate their overall responsibility; they remain collectively responsible for every decision taken with their authority.

Board of trustees vs board of directors, side by side

Board of trustees (charity)Board of directors (company)
Acts forThe charity's purposes, for the public benefitThe company's members as a whole
RegulatorCharity CommissionCompanies House
Main lawCharity law and the governing documentCompanies Act 2006 and the articles
PaidNormally not; reasonable expenses onlyExecutives on salary; non-executives on a fee
Personal liabilityUnlimited in an unincorporated charity; the charity is liable if incorporatedThe company is a separate legal body; directors answer for breach of their duties
Typical timeA few meetings a year plus committee work12 to 24 days a year for a private company NED

When trustees are also directors: the charitable company

The Commission's Charity types: how to choose a structure (CC22a) describes four main charity structures. A charitable company, usually limited by guarantee, must register with both the Charity Commission, if eligible, and Companies House. Its trustees are its directors under company law, and CC3 notes that company law and the Charities Act impose similar duties on directors of charitable companies, with company law governing how they are appointed and removed.

A charitable incorporated organisation, or CIO, is a corporate body registered only with the Commission; it does not exist until the Commission registers it. In a foundation CIO the trustees are the only members, while an association CIO has a wider voting membership. Trusts and unincorporated associations are not corporate bodies, so their trustees sign contracts personally, and CC3 says their personal liability is unlimited. Other charities must register with the Commission once their income reaches £5,000 a year.

Pay, liability and disqualification

The biggest practical difference is money. Charity trustees are normally unpaid: the Commission's guidance in Charity Commission guidance CC11, trustee expenses and payments says payments to trustees need proper authority, while reasonable expenses can be claimed. Company non-executives are paid; the BDO AIM 100 remuneration report 2025 found a median base fee of £58,000 on the AIM 100. Private company fees are lower and not surveyed.

Disqualification rules differ too. CC3 says you must not act as a trustee if you are disqualified under the Charities Act, for reasons including being an undischarged bankrupt, an unspent conviction for dishonesty or deception, or being on the sex offenders' register, although the Commission can waive some of them. Company directors face their own disqualification regime under company law.

Which board seat suits a portfolio career

  • A trustee seat is the most open door onto a board. Charities recruit for skills, particularly finance, digital, legal and fundraising, and the experience of governing, reading accounts and holding a chief executive to account is the same skill a company board looks for.
  • A company NED seat pays and carries the seven general duties in the Companies Act from day one. It is harder to win without board experience, which is why many executives start as a trustee.
  • A charitable company gives you both at once: you are a trustee and a company director, so your first trustee role can also be your first directorship.
  • Paid executive work for the same charity is a different matter. A trustee who is also a fractional executive for that charity needs the authority the Commission's guidance requires, and it is usually cleaner to keep the two apart.

Listing on getoperators

On getoperators there is no registration fee and nothing is taken from your rate. You set the day rate, it is shown on your public profile with your availability, and companies contact you directly; you contract with them and invoice them yourself. When a company engages someone it met here, the company pays getoperators a fee of its own, on top of your rate, never out of it. Every profile is checked by hand against LinkedIn and a CV before it goes live, and only people who have held the seat are accepted. Operator Pro, an optional membership, gives more visibility in your seat, and you do not need it to be listed.

Trustee seats are unpaid, so most portfolio executives pair one with paid fractional work. In the UK the published fractional bands include £800 to £1,500 a day for a CFO and £600 to £1,100 for a people lead. Simon A., the UK's first chief data officer, and Laura T., whose career runs through Dyson and 20th Century Fox, are on the bench with their rates and availability shown before any company calls.

Common questions

What is the difference between a trustee and a director of a charity?

In a charitable company there is often none: the trustees are the company's directors under company law and its charity trustees under charity law. In a trust or unincorporated charity there are no company directors, only trustees.

Do members of a board of trustees get paid in the UK?

Normally not. The Charity Commission says payments to trustees need proper authority, though trustees can claim reasonable expenses such as travel. Company non-executive directors, by contrast, are usually paid a fee.

Are charity trustees personally liable for the charity's debts?

In a trust or unincorporated association, the Charity Commission's CC3 says trustees' personal liability is unlimited, because they sign contracts personally. In a charitable company or CIO, the charity itself is usually liable.

Which regulator oversees a board of trustees compared with a company board?

The Charity Commission regulates charities and their trustees. Companies House registers companies and their directors. A charitable company deals with both.

More of them, on hiring, contracts and what a fractional engagement costs, on the fractional executive FAQ.

Read next

Related reading

Join the benchMore writing