Non-executive chair vs executive chair, side by side
| Non-executive chair | Executive chair | |
|---|---|---|
| Leads the board | Yes | Yes |
| Manages part of the business | No | Yes, by agreement with the chief executive |
| Time | Part time, set in the letter of appointment | Often several days a week |
| Appointed by | A letter of appointment | A letter of appointment plus a service contract |
| Paid by | A fee | A salary, often with bonus or equity |
| Independent under the Code | Can be, and should be on appointment | No; working in the business fails the test |
| Can sit on the remuneration committee (listed) | Yes, if independent on appointment, but not as its chair | No |
What the UK Corporate Governance Code says about the chair
Principle G asks for a clear division of responsibilities between the leadership of the board and the executive leadership of the business, and says no individual or small group should dominate the board's decisions. Provision 9 turns that into practice: the chair should be independent on appointment, judged against the Provision 10 tests, and the roles of chair and chief executive should not be held by the same person. Provision 14 asks for the responsibilities of the chair, the chief executive and the senior independent director to be set out in writing, agreed by the board and published.
An executive chair cannot meet the independence test, so a listed company that appoints one is departing from Provision 9 and has to explain it. The Code also says the chair should not stay beyond nine years from first appointment to the board, with a limited extension if explained. And Provision 24 keeps the chair of the board off the audit committee altogether.
The three situations that produce an executive chair
- The founder steps back. The founder hands the chief executive title to a hired CEO and keeps the chair with an executive brief, often product, fundraising or a few key customers.
- The turnaround. Investors put in an experienced operator as executive chair to fix a business quickly, often alongside or above a weakened chief executive, with a plan to step back to non-executive once it is stable.
- The gap between chief executives. The chair takes on executive duties while the board searches for a new CEO, which the Code treats as a temporary departure to explain.
When it works, and when it quietly fails
An executive chair works when the split is written down, the executive brief is narrow, and there is a date when it ends. It fails when the chief executive is never quite allowed to be chief executive: staff go round them to the chair, the chair re-opens decisions at board meetings, and the best candidates for the CEO job turn it down because they can see what is happening.
The safeguards are the ones the Code reaches for. A senior independent director the other non-executives trust, so someone can raise the issue with the chair. A written division of responsibilities, reviewed every year. And a strong independent voice on the board, because once the chair is executive, nobody leading the board is independent of management.
What each is paid
At the top of the market, the Spencer Stuart UK Board Index 2023 put average total remuneration for a board chair at £433,935 across the 150 largest companies with a premium London listing, nearly all of them non-executive. For comparison, the same survey's average base fee for an ordinary NED was £76,868. An executive chair in a private company is paid as an executive, on a salary negotiated like any senior hire, and there is no published survey that separates their pay from other executives'. Neither figure applies to a private company chair working two days a month, whose fee is a negotiation.
The cheaper fix for a founder who cannot let go
Many companies end up with an executive chair because the founder does not trust anyone else to run a part of the business they built. Often the real gap is a function, not a title: finance, operations or go to market. A fractional executive fills the function without changing the board. In the UK a fractional COO is published at £700 to £1,300 a day and a fractional CMO at £700 to £1,300. Caroline H. ran $200m to $400m P&Ls at Calo, Moove, Bird and Deliveroo, and Julian M. has been CMO at six fintech and SaaS companies. A company that engages an executive it met on getoperators pays 15% of the engagement's first-year value, only on a hire, with a minimum of £3,500. There is no retainer to start. When the bench has no fit, Operator Search returns a researched shortlist in 5 business days for £2,500 up front. For a permanent chief executive or chair, getoperators runs retained search.
| Full-time search | Fractional executive from getoperators | |
|---|---|---|
| See the name, day rate and availability before a call | No | Yes |
| Cost to start | A retainer, for most retained searches | Nothing until you engage |
| Time to someone in the seat | Months, plus notice period | Met in days, in the seat in one to three weeks |
| Fee | A share of first-year salary | 15% of first-year value, only on a hire, minimum £3,500 |
| Who you get | Whoever the search finds | Executives who have held the seat, verified against LinkedIn and CV |
Common questions
What is an executive chairman in a UK company?
A chair who leads the board and also has an executive role in the business, usually on a service contract and a salary. It is common in founder-led and turnaround companies and is a departure from the UK Corporate Governance Code for listed ones.
Is a non-executive chairman independent?
They can be. The UK Corporate Governance Code says the chair should be independent on appointment, assessed against the Provision 10 tests. A non-executive chair who was recently an employee or represents a major shareholder would not be.
Can an executive chairman and a CEO work in the same company?
Yes, and that is the usual set-up. It works when their responsibilities are written down and agreed by the board, as Provision 14 of the UK Code expects, and when there is a plan for the chair to step back.
Does an executive chair sit on the audit committee?
Not under the UK Code. Provision 24 says the chair of the board should not be a member of the audit committee, whether executive or non-executive.
More of them, on hiring, contracts and what a fractional engagement costs, on the fractional executive FAQ.
Read next
Related reading
- Same Table, Different Law. Board of Trustees vs Board of Directors, and Which Seat Suits Your Portfolio
- Managing Director vs COO: One Runs the Company, One Runs the Machine. Which Do You Need?
- CEO vs Owner: Is the CEO the Owner? Only Sometimes, and the Law Says Who Can Fire Whom
- Retained vs Contingency Search: Which Fits Your Role