Chairman vs CEO side by side
| Chair | CEO | |
|---|---|---|
| Leads | The board | The company and its executive team |
| Time | Part time, usually a set number of days a month | Full time |
| Executive or not | Non-executive in most UK companies | Executive |
| Main relationship | Shareholders and the other directors | The leadership team, customers, investors |
| Power over the other | Leads the board that appoints and can remove the CEO | Runs the business the chair oversees |
| Judged on | Whether the board works and the right CEO is in place | Results |
What the UK Corporate Governance Code says
The UK Corporate Governance Code, published by the Financial Reporting Council (FRC), is the rulebook for boards of listed companies. The current version is the 2024 Code, which applies to financial years beginning on or after 1 January 2025, and on the FRC's own page it applies to companies listed in the commercial companies category or the closed-ended investment funds category, on a comply or explain basis: a company either follows each provision or explains publicly why it does not.
The Code says the chair leads the board and is responsible for its overall effectiveness in directing the company. It says leadership of the board should be separate from executive leadership of the business, and Provision 9 sets out the practical rules: the chair should be independent on appointment, the roles of chair and chief executive should not be held by the same person, and a chief executive should not go on to become chair of the same company, unless, exceptionally, the board consults major shareholders in advance and explains its reasons.
The Code also expects at least half the board, excluding the chair, to be independent non-executive directors, and a senior independent director to act as a sounding board for the chair and a route for shareholders if the chair relationship breaks down. Provision 19 says a chair should not stay in post beyond nine years from first joining the board, with a limited extension allowed if explained.
Why the split matters
- The board's job includes judging the chief executive. A board chaired by the chief executive is marking its own homework.
- It spreads power: no single person sets the board agenda and runs the business it is reviewing.
- It gives the CEO somewhere to take hard problems that is not their own team.
- It makes succession possible: the chair can run a search for the next CEO without the current one controlling it.
- It reassures investors and lenders, which is why private equity and venture investors often ask for an independent chair once they own a stake.
Who is senior, the chairman or the CEO?
On paper the chair is senior, because the chair leads the board and the board appoints and can remove the chief executive. In practice the chief executive has far more day-to-day power, a team, a budget and full-time knowledge of the business. A good relationship is a partnership in which the chair does not run the company and the CEO does not run the board.
Executive chair is the exception: one person chairs the board and also holds an executive role. It is common in founder-led and owner-managed companies, and some listed companies use it for a period with an explanation to shareholders under comply or explain.
What chairs are paid, and what that means for a growing company
In the largest UK listed companies, the Spencer Stuart UK Board Index 2023 reports average total remuneration of £433,935 for a board chair, covering the 150 largest companies with a premium London listing. That is the top of the market and a long way from what a private company pays for a part-time chair. The getoperators guide to non-executive director fees covers the sourced figures for smaller companies.
A founder-led private company usually does not need an independent chair on day one. It needs one when outside money, a sale process or a board that has stopped challenging the founder makes the case. James W., a former global head of audit for investment banking at Credit Suisse and UBS, is on the getoperators bench as a non-executive director and board chair, as well as a fractional head of internal audit, with his rate and availability shown before you call.
When the chief executive needs a senior team, not a chair
Many founders searching CEO vs chairman are really asking whether they need help above them or beside them. If the problem is accountability, investor confidence or succession, it is a chair. If the problem is that the CEO is running finance, operations and the board pack alone, it is a senior executive, often fractional.
A fractional CFO in the UK runs £800 to £1,500 a day and a fractional COO £700 to £1,300. On getoperators, the only open bench where you see the name, day rate and availability before a call, Paddy A. spent eight years at Deloitte and was global CFO of Moltex, and Emma B. was EMEA chief of staff at Adobe and worked at Microsoft. A company that engages an executive it met on getoperators pays 15% of the engagement's first-year value, only on a hire, with a minimum of £3,500 in the UK, $4,800 in the US or AED 17,500 in the UAE. There is no retainer to start. When the bench has no fit, Operator Search returns a researched shortlist in 5 business days for £2,500 up front.
| Full-time search | Fractional executive from getoperators | |
|---|---|---|
| See the name, day rate and availability before a call | No | Yes |
| Cost to start | A retainer, for most retained searches | Nothing until you engage |
| Time to someone in the seat | Months, plus notice period | Met in days, in the seat in one to three weeks |
| Fee | 25 to 33 per cent of first-year salary in the UK | 15% of first-year value, only on a hire, minimum £3,500 |
| Who you get | Whoever the search finds | Executives who have held the seat, profiles verified against LinkedIn and CV |
| Contract | Employment | Directly with the executive, days agreed between you |
Common questions
Can the same person be chairman and CEO of a UK company?
Yes, it is legal, and common in owner-managed companies. For companies applying the UK Corporate Governance Code, the Code expects the roles to be held by different people, so a listed company combining them has to explain why to its shareholders.
Does the CEO report to the chairman?
The CEO reports to the board, and the chair leads the board, so in practice the chair is the CEO's main point of contact and usually leads the CEO's appraisal. The chair does not manage the CEO day to day.
Should a retiring chief executive become the chair?
Under the UK Corporate Governance Code, generally no: a chief executive should not go on to chair the same company unless major shareholders have been consulted in advance and the reasons are explained. The concern is that the new CEO is overseen by their predecessor.
Is chair or chairman the right word?
Both are used. The UK Corporate Governance Code uses chair, and most UK boards have moved to it. Chairman and chairwoman are still common in older articles of association and in search queries.
More of them, on hiring, contracts and what a fractional engagement costs, on the fractional executive FAQ.
Read next
Related reading
- CEO vs CFO: The Partnership Investors Actually Back, and When a Fractional CFO Is Enough
- CIO vs CTO: Which One to Hire First, by the Kind of Company You Run
- Executive Chairman or Non-Executive Chairman? The Title Decides Who Really Runs the Company
- Managing Director vs COO: One Runs the Company, One Runs the Machine. Which Do You Need?