CIO vs CTO: Which One to Hire First, by the Kind of Company You Run

CIO vs CTO comes down to who the technology is for: a chief information officer runs the technology a company uses to operate, and a chief technology officer builds the technology the company sells. If your product is software, you almost always need a CTO first; if your product is something else and technology is how you run the business, you usually need a CIO, or a smaller version of one, first. Plenty of guides define the two titles. This one is a decision guide: which seat a company should fill first, by the kind of company it is, what each costs, the warning signs that you hired the wrong one, and when one fractional leader can cover both for a while.

The executives named here are on the getoperators bench as of November 2026, and every detail about them is from their own profile. getoperators does not publish a salary band for this title, so pay is described from the neighbouring seats it does publish.

The one-line difference

A CTO faces the customer through the product: architecture, engineering team, roadmap, the reliability of what is sold. A CIO faces the business: the finance system, the CRM, devices and access, IT suppliers, internal data and the automation of internal work. Both are senior technology leaders, and in large companies both sit on the executive committee. In growing companies there is usually money for one, and choosing the wrong one costs a year.

If you want the full explainer for either title, there are separate guides to what a CIO is and what a CTO is, linked below. The rest of this page is about the choice.

Which to hire first, by company type

Company typeHire firstWhy
Software or SaaS startupCTOThe product is the technology. Internal IT can run on good tools and a part-time admin for years.
Fintech or regulated techCTO, with security cover earlyThe product is still the technology, but regulators and banking partners will ask about security and resilience early.
Professional services firmCIO or head of ITNothing is sold as software; the risk is in systems, data, access and client confidentiality.
Retailer or ecommerce brandDepends on the platformBuilt your own platform: CTO. Run on a standard platform with many integrations: CIO.
Manufacturer or logistics firmCIOERP, warehouse and operational systems are the backbone; a failed migration stops the business.
PE-backed buy-and-buildCIOEvery acquisition brings its own systems, and integrating them is where the value plan lives or dies.
Marketplace or platform businessCTOThe platform is the product, even if it sells someone else's goods or services.

Warning signs you hired the wrong one

The mismatch shows up in a predictable way, usually within six months.

  • A CIO in a software company: the roadmap slows, engineers feel managed by process rather than led, and the best ones leave
  • A CTO in a services or manufacturing business: an ambitious rebuild is proposed where a well-run off-the-shelf system would do, and the finance system migration has no owner
  • Either one, wrong way round: the board asks a technology question and the answer is about the other half of the estate
  • Security sits between the two and nobody owns it, which is when a CISO, or a fractional one, belongs in the conversation

What each seat costs

getoperators publishes a CTO salary band but not a separate CIO band. A full-time CTO in a UK company of twenty to two hundred people is paid a base of £115,000 to £185,000, and the cost calculator puts a full-time CTO's first year at about £196,000 once employer costs and recruitment are added. A CIO at the same company size is usually hired in a similar range, with the top end set by how large and regulated the estate is.

Fractionally, a CTO is priced at £800 to £1,400 a day in the UK, £6,133 to £10,733 a month at two days a week, and in the US the monthly band at two days a week is $6,000 to $16,000. A fractional data leader, often the right partner for a CIO-shaped problem that is really about reporting, is priced at £700 to £1,200 a day.

When one fractional leader can cover both

Below about fifty people, the honest answer is often neither as a full-time hire. A senior fractional technology leader two days a week can set the product architecture and also choose the finance system, sort out access and devices, and put basic security in place. The day that stops working is the day either half needs a full-time owner, and by then the fractional leader can write the job description for it.

On the bench are technology leaders on both sides of the line: John A., whose background spans AWS, Amazon and Snowflake; Chris C., a US CTO; Sergey M., formerly at Binance and a CTO in the UAE; Simon A., the UK's first chief data officer, with a career through Bupa, Tesco, UBS, IBM and Lloyd's of London; and Nick V., a chief data officer. You see each one's day rate and availability before a call.

Hiring a technology leader, compared

You book directly, nothing is paid to start, and the company pays 15% of first-year value only if it engages someone it met here, minimum £3,500 in the UK or $4,800 in the US.

Full-time hire through retained searchContingency recruitergetoperators
See the name, day rate and availability before a callNoNoYes
Has held the seat beforeUsually, after a long processVariesBench of people who have been a CTO, CIO or head of technology or equivalent
CheckedBy the search firmBy the recruiterProfile verified against LinkedIn and CV by hand
Cost to startRetainer up frontNothing until placementNothing until you engage
Fee25 to 33 per cent of first-year salary in the UKA percentage of salary on placement15% of first-year value, minimum £3,500
Time to someone in the seatMonthsWeeks to monthsMet in days, in the seat in one to three weeks

Common questions

Should a SaaS startup hire a CIO or a CTO first?

A CTO. In a software company the product is the technology, so the first technology leader must own architecture and the engineering team. Internal IT can be handled by good tools and light support until the company is much larger.

Which is more senior, a chief information officer or a chief technology officer?

Neither by default. In companies that have both, they are peers who report to the chief executive. Which one carries more weight depends on whether the business sells technology or uses it to run.

Can one person be both CIO and CTO in a small company?

Often, yes, until the company is large enough that either the product or the internal estate needs a full-time owner. A fractional technology leader is a common way to cover both in the meantime.

Does a manufacturer need a CTO at all?

Usually only if it builds technology into its products, such as connected devices or software. Otherwise the senior technology seat is a CIO or head of IT who owns ERP, operational systems and suppliers.

More of them, on hiring, contracts and what a fractional engagement costs, on the fractional executive FAQ.

Read next

Related reading

Browse the benchMore writing