The seven general duties, sections 171 to 177
Section 170 says the general duties are owed by a director to the company, which means it is the company, not a shareholder or a creditor, that normally enforces them. Section 178 says a breach has the same consequences as breaching the old common law and equitable rules the duties replaced.
| Section | Duty | What it means in practice |
|---|---|---|
| 171 | Duty to act within powers | Follow the company's constitution, including its articles, and use powers only for the purposes they were given. |
| 172 | Duty to promote the success of the company | Act in good faith in the way most likely to benefit the members as a whole, having regard to the factors listed below. |
| 173 | Duty to exercise independent judgment | Make up your own mind. Do not let an investor, a founder or anyone else exercise your powers for you. |
| 174 | Duty to exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence | Meet the standard of a reasonably diligent person with the knowledge expected of someone in your role, and the higher standard if you know more. |
| 175 | Duty to avoid conflicts of interest | Avoid situations where your interests conflict, or may conflict, with the company's, including using its information or opportunities. |
| 176 | Duty not to accept benefits from third parties | Do not accept a benefit given because you are a director, unless it cannot reasonably be seen as creating a conflict. |
| 177 | Duty to declare interest in proposed transaction or arrangement | Tell the other directors about any direct or indirect interest in a deal before the company enters into it. |
Section 172 and the factors a board has to weigh
Section 172 is the duty boards argue about most. A director must act in the way they consider, in good faith, would be most likely to promote the success of the company for the benefit of its members as a whole, and in doing so have regard, among other matters, to six factors set out in the Act.
- The likely consequences of any decision in the long term
- The interests of the company's employees
- The need to foster the company's business relationships with suppliers, customers and others
- The impact of the company's operations on the community and the environment
- The desirability of the company maintaining a reputation for high standards of business conduct
- The need to act fairly as between members of the company
What the duties mean for a non-executive director
The Act does not distinguish between executive and non-executive directors. A NED owes exactly the same seven duties as the chief executive from the day they are appointed. What differs is how section 174 is measured: the standard is set partly by the functions the director actually carries out, so a NED is judged as someone whose job is to read the papers, ask questions and challenge, not to run the finance function.
That is not a lower bar in practice. A NED who signs off accounts they have not read, or who does not ask about a risk they could see, is exposed. The usual protections are directors' and officers' insurance, a proper letter of appointment, minutes that record their challenge, and the discipline of not agreeing to anything they do not understand.
Companies House's own guidance on gov.uk says the duties still apply if you act as a director without being formally appointed. That is the point at which the duties stop being only a board member's problem.
Shadow directors, de facto directors and the fractional executive
Section 250 says a director includes any person occupying the position of director, by whatever name called. Section 251 defines a shadow director as a person in accordance with whose directions or instructions the directors of the company are accustomed to act, and says a person is not one merely because the directors act on advice they give in a professional capacity.
That is the line a fractional executive, an advisor or an investor needs to keep in view. A fractional CFO who prepares the forecast, recommends a funding route and presents to the board is giving professional advice. A fractional CFO whose instructions the board simply carries out, who negotiates and signs as if they were a director and who is described to lenders as one, is drifting towards being treated as a director in law, with the duties and the exposure that come with it.
| Appointed director (incl. NED) | Advisor | Fractional executive, not on the board | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Owes the seven general duties | Yes, from appointment | No, unless they become a shadow director | No, unless they act as or become a director in law |
| Vote on the board | Yes | No | No |
| Where the risk sits | Every decision of the board | Advice the board always follows | Instructions the board always follows, or acting as a director |
| Protection | D&O insurance, minutes, letter of appointment | A written advisory agreement | A contract that defines the role, D&O cover if they attend the board |
Keeping a fractional executive on the right side of the line
- Put the role in writing: what they own, who they report to, and that decisions reserved to the board stay with the board.
- Let them present to the board, not vote. Minute their recommendation and the board's decision separately.
- Do not describe them as a director on the website, in a pitch deck or to a lender unless they have been appointed.
- If the company wants them to act as a director, appoint them properly and give them D&O cover. That is cleaner for everybody.
- For legal questions on board structure, a fractional general counsel can help; the UK band is £800 to £1,400 a day. getoperators does not have a general counsel on the bench yet, and for a full-time appointment it runs retained search.
Common questions
What are the seven directors' duties in sections 171 to 177?
To act within powers (171), promote the success of the company (172), exercise independent judgment (173), exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence (174), avoid conflicts of interest (175), not accept benefits from third parties (176), and declare an interest in a proposed transaction or arrangement (177).
Who enforces a director's duties under the Companies Act 2006?
Section 170 says the general duties are owed to the company, so the company normally enforces them. Shareholders can in some cases bring a derivative claim on the company's behalf; take legal advice before relying on that.
Can a fractional CFO be treated as a shadow director?
It is possible. Section 251 defines a shadow director as someone whose directions or instructions the directors are accustomed to act on, while excluding advice given in a professional capacity. Keep the role advisory and reporting, and appoint them properly if they are to act as a director.
Does section 174 hold a NED to a lower standard than an executive?
The bar is set by the role rather than lowered. The standard is a reasonably diligent person with the knowledge expected of someone carrying out that director's functions, plus any extra knowledge the director actually has. A NED with a finance background is held to that background.
More of them, on hiring, contracts and what a fractional engagement costs, on the fractional executive FAQ.
Read next
Related reading
- What Is an Interim CFO? When Full-Time Cover Beats a Fractional One, and When It Does Not
- Lawyers On Demand Alternatives: Interim GCs and Flexible Lawyers Compared
- CEO vs Chairman: Why the Most Powerful Person in the Room Is Not Supposed to Run the Board
- Corporate Governance Is Not a Listed-Company Problem. What It Means for a 50-Person Business
- Overboarding: Why Investors Count Your Board Seats, and How Many Roles You Can Really Hold